WootBot


quality posts: 14 Private Messages WootBot

Staff

One thing that I've never understood is competitive parenting. It's not a sport, people. There is no gold medal at the end. Just because your kids started crawling a week before mine doesn't mean your child is better than my child, and it definitely has no bearing on your perceived superiority as a mother.

I haven't experienced this firsthand, but a friend of a friend (this totally sounds like I'm making it up, but I promise I'm not) is one of the worst offenders I've ever encountered, to the point where she flat out lies about her child's abilities. "Zoe is only 3 months old but she's already walking! Isn't she AMAZING?!" That's an exaggeration, but you get the point.

What I don't get is, why? Why would you make that up? No one is keeping score. What worries me the most is that she's setting her kid up for failure with completely unrealistic expectations. What happens when she's 5 and doesn't win first place at Field Day? Or when she's 18 and only had a 3.96 gpa instead of a 4.0? Kids don't need that kind of undue pressure. They need encouragement and support and the confidence to know that as long as they try their best, you're behind them. That's not to say you shouldn't challenge them. But let's be reasonable.

Know anyone like this? Tell us your story.

 

Photo by Flickr member cradlehall, used under a Creative Commons License.

bringitonhome


quality posts: 2 Private Messages bringitonhome

Yeah, I think sometimes people are just that ignorant about developmental milestones and prone to overinterpreting the significance of their child's behavior that they really believe what they're bragging about to have some truthiness to it. But I don't care for it no matter what motivates it. Like when you can't mention anything your kid does or did without getting a one-up response? Not a conversation. To be fair, though, I've met plenty of folks without kids who do the same thing, so it probably has little to do with children. It's just more irritating when they're brought into it.

awillis2008


quality posts: 0 Private Messages awillis2008

The competitive wears off as your children become older and eventually teenagers. Parents find they have less to brag about and are often times looking for someone to confide in. It seems the earlier they start 'doing' things, the sooner they instigate and the sooner they disappoint. My parenting philosophy... always have a mind on the future and where you kid will be one day and do those things that will help get them there. My 3 year old is in love with space, is it unrealistic to set goals that may one day help her to become an astronaut? I realize those goals will change but thats where you need flexibility in changing goals and creating new ones. She can become a pilot, a doctor... or a waitress or customer service rep... whatever, she will be prepared and supported.

Now, for real competitive parenting, I bet my parent can beat your parent in a full on WCW fight (on Wii).

ALex Willis

kats2882


quality posts: 0 Private Messages kats2882

My mother was like this and it never let up. If I wasn't first, then it wasn't good enough. I had a very high GPA, varsity sports, and even had fox do a newscast on me. I asked her once why she was never satisfied. Her reply was she always had to have things to brag about. I felt that my worth was based on honors/awards only. I'm thirty and still seeing a therapist. I don't agree with or condone this type of behavior. You want a screwed up kid, be a competitive parent.

runnerfrog13


quality posts: 10 Private Messages runnerfrog13
kats2882 wrote:My mother was like this and it never let up. If I wasn't first, then it wasn't good enough. I had a very high GPA, varsity sports, and even had fox do a newscast on me. I asked her once why she was never satisfied. Her reply was she always had to have things to brag about. I felt that my worth was based on honors/awards only. I'm thirty and still seeing a therapist. I don't agree with or condone this type of behavior. You want a screwed up kid, be a competitive parent.


This is why I'm not a fan of that whole "Tiger Parent" craze. Kids don't need that kind of pressure, they need love. That's all I ever wanted from my parents, was for them to be proud of me, encourage me in the things that I cared about. Not to ask "How come you got a B+?" instead of an A.

It can be a hard path to follow though, because it's so touchy where support/encouragement/expressing pride to your children becomes them feeling your expectations and never meeting them. I think the best thing that I heard was to express pride in their effort rather than how you feel or the result (for example "You worked so HARD practicing for that game!" instead of "You won!" See how it shifts the focus to their determination rather than the outcome?)

ibpa


quality posts: 0 Private Messages ibpa

Any competitive desire should come from within, and should be for yourself. Many of these so-called parents are trying to live their childhoods over again through their children. Yes. They want the best for them, but do you really think all the external stress is what is good for them? You can help guide them by giving them support in what they want to excel at, but pushing your desires on them is not good.

amynance


quality posts: 5 Private Messages amynance

Staff

[quote postid="5135833" user="runnerfrog13"]This is why "How come you got a B+?" instead of an A.

This was my Dad. If it was an A- why wasn't it an A? If it was an A, why not an A+? It didn't make me work harder. It made me feel like no matter how hard I worked, it would never be good enough. Then one day I stopped caring what he thought and just did it for myself. Made it a lot easier to deal with.